TABLE 3. Alternate treatment of TAC
nonresponders with TCAs or HCAs
Antidepressant |
Ref. |
Sample and Dosage |
Prior Medication and Design |
Results |
|||
Tricyclics (TCAs) |
|
|
|
|
|||
Desipramine Imipramine Imipramine Imipramine |
Charney et al. (13) Reimherr et al. (86) Peselow et al. (74) McGrath et al. (58) |
11 UP inpatients (DMI; 2.5 mg/kg) 27 UP outpatients (IMI; 150-300 mg) 15 UP outpatients (IMI; 150-300 mg) UP outpatients, n = 22 atypical depression (IMI: 150-300 mg/day) |
TCAs (by history), open label TCAs (by history),double blind Paroxetine, double blind crossover Pheneizine (60-90), double
blind crossover |
1 of 11 (9%) responders 8 of 27 (30%) responders 11 of 15 (73%) responders 9 of 22 (41%) responders |
|||
Approved Heterocyclics (HCAs) Bupropion Nomifensine |
Stern et al. (100) Nolen et al. (69) Schmauss et al. (92) |
30 UP inpatients (BUP, 675 mg/d; n = 19; PBO, n = 11); 4 weeks 55 UP outpatients, > 2 wks of BUP, 350 mg 10 UP inpatients 20 Recurrent UP and BP inpatients |
TCAs (by history), placebo
controlled IMI, double blind 4 week controlled trial, followed
by open label BUP TCAs (by history), double blind crossover vs.TCP TCAs (by history), open label |
BUP significantly better
than PBO on
CGI and HRSD (response rate
not reported ) Significant improvement in
both intolerant
(n = 18) and resistant
(n = 38) patients on CGI
and HRSD (response rate
not reported) 1 of 10 (10%) 4 of 20 (20%) (pooled; po,
30%, n = 10; iv, 10%, n =10) |
|||
Trazodone |
Cole et al. (14) |
25 outpatients (mixed UP, BP) TRAZ: 264 mg. |
TCAs (by history), open lable |
14 of 25 (56%) responders |
|||
Trazodone Oxaprotiline |
Cole et al. (14) Nolen et al. (68) |
25 outpatients (mixed UP, BP) TRAZ: 264 mg. Initial drug: n = 33, UP inpatients (260 mg); crossover: n = 31, UP inpatients (267 mg) |
TCAs (by history), open label TCAs (by history), double blind; TCAs (by history) +
FLV, double blind crossover |
9 of 33 (27%) 12 of 31 38% |
} |
|
|
SRIs |
|
|
|
|
|||
Fluoxetine |
Reimherr et al. (86) |
40 UP outpatients FLU: 60-80 mg/d 35 UP outpatients FLU: 60-80 mg/d |
TCAs (by history), double blind Confirmed TCA nonresponse, double blind |
17 of 40 (43%) responders 18 of 35 (51%) responders |
|||
Fluoxamine |
Beasley et al. (7) Nolen et al. (69) |
Initial drug: n = 35, UP inpatients (288 mg); crossover: n = 21, UP inpatients (286 mg) |
TCAs (by history), double blind TCAs (by history) + OXAP, double blind |
0 of 35 (0%) 2 of 21 (10%) |
} |
|
|
Paroxetine Viqualine |
Delgado et al. (20) White et al. (117) Peselow et al. (74) Gagiano et al. (34) Faravelli et al. (28) |
28 UP; inpatients (n = 21), outpatients (n = 7) 12 UP outpatients FLV: 50-300 md/d 10 UP outpatients PAR: 30-50 mg/d 28 UP outpatients; PAR: 30 mg/d 20 UP outpatients |
TCAs (by history), open label DMI 150-300 mg/d, 6 weeks; double blind crossover IMI 150- 250 mg/d, 6 weeks; double blind crossover TCAs (13 by history, 15 AMI), open label TCA {ewc MVIMG,
MVIMAGE,!greateq.bmp} 150 mg > 4 weeks, double blind crossover |
Pooled: 8 of 28 (28%) responders
Inpatients:
14% (3/21) Outpatients:
71% (5/7) 9 or 12 (75%) responders 5 of 10 (50%) responders 18 of 28 (64%) responders 5 of 10 (50%) VIQ 0
of 10 (0%) PBO VIQ
> PBO |
|||
published 2000